How to Sell a Car With a Blown Engine (and What It's Worth)

By ScrapMyJunkCar Team. Updated . Sources are listed at the end. How we work

Yes, you can sell a car with a blown engine. Your main options are selling it as-is to a private buyer, trading it in, selling it to a junk car buyer or salvage yard, or replacing the engine first and selling it as a running car.

For most older, lower-value cars, replacing the engine costs more than the car will be worth afterward, so selling it as-is or junking it usually comes out ahead. For newer or higher-value cars, a replacement engine can make sense. The rest of this guide shows you how to run the numbers, which option fits your situation, and how to avoid getting shortchanged.

First, Make Sure the Engine Is Really “Blown”

“Blown engine” gets used loosely. It can mean anything from a failed head gasket to a thrown rod that punched a hole in the block. Before you sell, get a diagnosis, because a car that needs a single repair is a very different sale than one that needs a whole engine.

Common warning signs include:

  • Knocking, banging, or tapping from a running engine. AAA says these sounds usually mean valves, pistons, or rods are striking metal and “could bend or break beyond repair.” Its advice is to shut the engine off and get it to a mechanic.
  • Overheating, steam, or a burning smell. AAA notes that ignoring coolant leaks can lead to overheating, “which could lead to a cracked engine block or blown head gasket.”
  • Oil starvation. AAA warns that ignoring oil leaks can cause engine damage from poor lubrication.
  • The engine won’t turn over at all, or it cranks but won’t run after a loud noise or a sudden loss of power.

Once you know what failed, ask the shop for a written estimate. You’ll need it to compare options, and a serious buyer may want to see it.

Check for a recall or extended warranty

Before you sell, run your VIN through a recall lookup. NHTSA says a VIN search will show whether a specific vehicle needs a recall repair, and that recall remedies are done by a dealer for free. Some manufacturers have also extended warranties on certain engines. If your engine problem is covered, the math changes completely. You can check with our VIN decoder and recall check or directly on NHTSA’s site.

What Engine Repair or Replacement Costs

Here’s what published sources report. These are averages; your quote will depend on the car, the engine, and local labor rates.

Repair Reported cost Source and what it covers
Connecting rod bearings $500 to $1,500 AAA estimate for the repair
Pistons or engine rebuild $2,000 to $5,000+ AAA estimate
Professional engine rebuild $3,500 to $6,000 Kelley Blue Book
Remanufactured engine $5,000 to $9,000 for a mainstream vehicle Kelley Blue Book; installation by a third party could add $1,200 to $1,500 or more
New engine at a dealership Close to $8,000 on average Kelley Blue Book; high-output engines can cost three or four times that

For a deeper look at your replacement choices, see our guide to used vs. rebuilt vs. remanufactured engines.

How to Decide: Fix It or Sell It As-Is

Start with three numbers:

  1. Repair cost: the written estimate for the engine work, including labor.
  2. Value after repair: what the car would sell for running, given its age, mileage, and condition apart from the engine.
  3. Value as-is: what buyers will pay for it with the blown engine. Our junk car calculator gives a quick baseline, and real quotes will refine it.

If value after repair minus repair cost is less than or close to value as-is, fixing it doesn’t pay. You’d be spending money and time to end up roughly where you started.

A worked example

Say you have an older sedan that would sell for about $4,000 if it ran well. The shop recommends a remanufactured engine. Using Kelley Blue Book’s ranges, that’s $5,000 to $9,000 for the engine, plus $1,200 to $1,500 or more to install it if a third-party shop does the work.

Even at the low end, you’d spend more than $6,000 to own a $4,000 car. Unless you were planning to keep the car for years and the rest of it is in excellent shape, selling it as-is is the better move.

Now flip it. If the car is a few years old and worth well into five figures once running, a $6,000 to $10,000 engine job may be worth it. That’s when it’s worth getting two or three repair quotes.

Our guide on whether to fix or junk your car has a fuller checklist, including the hidden costs of keeping an aging car.

Your Options for Selling a Car With a Blown Engine

Option Best for Trade-offs
Private sale as-is Desirable models, project-car buyers, mechanics Slower, more calls, and you’ll need to explain the problem honestly
Dealer trade-in Cars you’re replacing anyway at the same dealer Expect a low allowance; the dealer may send it to auction
Junk car buyer or salvage yard Older or lower-value cars, cars that can’t be moved Offer is based on weight and parts, not on what the car was worth running
Repair, then sell Newer or higher-value cars Upfront cost and risk; you may not recover it

Private sale

Some buyers want a non-running car: hobbyists who’ll swap in an engine, mechanics who can do the work cheaply, or people shopping for a specific model. Be upfront in the listing (“engine knocking, does not run, mechanic’s diagnosis available”). Hiding a known engine problem can expose you to complaints or legal claims later.

Trade-in

A dealer will take almost anything as a trade, but a car with a dead engine usually gets a small allowance. If you go this route, get a junk or as-is quote first so you know whether the trade-in figure is fair.

Junk car buyer or salvage yard

This is often the simplest option. A junk buyer prices the car on its weight, the scrap market, and parts that still have value, such as the transmission, body panels, catalytic converter, and wheels. The engine being dead lowers the offer less than you might expect, because many buyers were never going to resell it as a running car. See how much a junk car is worth for what drives those offers.

Since the car can’t drive, confirm the buyer will tow it and that towing is included in the quote. Our guide to junking a car that doesn’t run covers how pickup works for a car that won’t start.

How to Get the Best Price

  • Describe the problem accurately. If you say it runs and it doesn’t, expect the offer to drop at pickup.
  • Get more than one quote. Offers vary between buyers and with scrap prices.
  • Leave the car complete. Pulling the catalytic converter, battery, or wheels can lower the offer, since buyers price the car as a complete unit. Ask before you remove anything.
  • Have your paperwork ready. A title in your name makes the sale faster and usually gets a better price. If yours is missing, sort that out before you list the car.
  • Remove your belongings and plates, and cancel insurance only after the car is gone.

Paperwork When You Sell

The steps are the same as any car sale:

  1. Sign over the title exactly as your state requires, including the odometer reading if it applies.
  2. Write a simple bill of sale that notes the car is sold as-is with a non-running engine.
  3. File your state’s notice of sale or release of liability so later tickets or fees aren’t tied to you.
  4. Keep copies of everything.

If you’d rather skip the classified ads, you can get a free offer from our buying partners. They make an offer based on your car’s details, tow it for free, and pay you at pickup.

FAQ

Can I sell a car with a blown engine to a dealer? Yes. Most dealers will take it as a trade-in, though the allowance is usually low. Compare it with a junk car or private-sale quote before you agree.

Is it worth replacing a blown engine? It depends on the car’s value once repaired. Kelley Blue Book puts a remanufactured engine at roughly $5,000 to $9,000 for a mainstream vehicle before installation, which often exceeds what an older car is worth.

Do I have to tell a buyer the engine is blown? You should. Disclose known problems in the listing and on the bill of sale. It protects you and keeps the sale clean.

Will a junk car buyer take a car that won’t start? Yes. Junk buyers routinely tow non-running cars. Ask whether towing is included and whether the offer depends on the car being complete.

Sources

Ready to sell your junk car?

Get a free cash offer in about 30 seconds. Towing is always free.

Get my offer

Ready to get that car off your hands?

Get a free offer in minutes. Towing is always free and you get paid at pickup.

Get my offer