Most junk car scams come down to one of three things: the buyer doesn’t pay what they promised, the payment itself is fake, or the paperwork leaves the car tied to your name after it’s gone.
The good news is that a few habits shut down nearly all of them. Get the offer in writing, don’t accept a check for more than the price, don’t pay anything upfront, sign the title only at handoff with the buyer’s name filled in, and file your state’s notice of sale right away.
Below are the eight scams sellers run into most, how each one works, and what to do instead.
1. The Bait-and-Switch Offer
How it works: You get a strong quote over the phone. When the tow truck shows up, the driver “finds” problems and cuts the offer, betting that you won’t send the truck away after taking time off to meet it.
How to avoid it:
- Describe the car accurately upfront: whether it runs, missing parts, body damage, flood or fire damage. Honest offers can still change if the description was wrong.
- Ask the buyer, before pickup, exactly what could change the price.
- Get the quote in writing (text or email) with the year, make, model, and condition you described.
- Be willing to say no at the curb. A legitimate buyer won’t pressure you.
Our guide on how to choose a junk car buyer covers why offers sometimes change for legitimate reasons, and how to tell the difference.
2. The Overpayment Check
How it works: This one targets people selling cars online. The FTC describes a “buyer” who can’t see the car in person and sends a check for more than the asking price, then asks you to send back the difference. The check looks real and the funds may show up in your account, but the FTC says the bank can take weeks to discover it’s fake, then reclaim the money. Anything you sent is gone.
The FTC’s data shows how costly these are. In 2019, people reported more than 27,000 fake check scams with losses topping $28 million, and the median loss was $1,988, compared to $320 across all fraud types.
How to avoid it:
- Refuse any check for more than the selling price.
- Never send money back to a buyer, by wire, gift card, money order, or crypto.
- Remember the FTC’s warning that when a bank says a check “cleared,” that doesn’t mean it was a good check.
3. Fake Payment App Notifications
How it works: The FTC warns that scammers posing as buyers insist on a payment app and then send a fake payment notification, hoping you hand over the item before you notice.
How to avoid it: The FTC’s advice is simple: don’t accept a mobile payment from someone you don’t know. Check your actual account balance, not an email or text, before the car leaves. For junk car sales, cash or a business check from an established, licensed buyer handed over at pickup is the norm.
4. “Buy This Vehicle History Report First”
How it works: The Better Business Bureau describes a scam where a “buyer” asks you to purchase a vehicle history report from a specific, unfamiliar website, usually for about $20 to $27. The site may just take your money, collect personal data like your driver’s license number, or install malware. The buyer never intended to buy.
How to avoid it: Be suspicious of any buyer who makes you buy something as a condition of the sale. If you want a history report, the BBB suggests using a provider approved by the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS).
5. The Verification Code Grab
How it works: A “buyer” asks you to read back a code they texted you, supposedly to prove you’re real. The FTC explains that with a Google Voice code, scammers can set up a number linked to your phone and use it to scam others.
How to avoid it: Never share any verification code with someone you don’t know.
6. Upfront and Surprise Fees
How it works: The buyer asks for a “towing fee,” “title processing fee,” or “environmental fee,” either before pickup or deducted at the curb.
How to avoid it: Ask for the full, final number in writing, including any deductions, before you schedule pickup. Many junk car buyers include towing in the offer. If someone wants you to pay before they’ve paid you, walk away.
7. The Unlicensed Buyer
How it works: Someone with a truck and no business license buys cars for cash, asks no questions about paperwork, and resells or scraps them however they like. If the car isn’t properly transferred, problems can come back to you.
How to avoid it: Many states license the businesses that dismantle or recycle vehicles, and you can check:
- California: The DMV licenses vehicle dismantlers, and its Occupational License Lookup lets you check dismantler license status.
- Texas: TDLR licenses used automotive parts recyclers, requires a separate license for each location and for each employee who buys or sells used parts, and offers a public license search.
Licensed junk yards, salvage yards, and auto recyclers must also report the vehicles they take in to NMVTIS at least monthly, which keeps the car’s junk status attached to its VIN. That’s one more reason to sell through a legitimate business. You can also look up established yards with our junkyard finder.
8. Title Tricks That Leave the Car in Your Name
How it works: The buyer asks you to sign the title but leave the buyer’s name blank (an “open title”), or simply never transfers it. If the car is later abandoned, ticketed, or used in a crime, the record still points to you.
How to avoid it:
- Fill in the buyer’s name, date, price, and odometer reading (where required) when you sign. Our guide to signing over a car title walks through each field.
- Write a bill of sale and keep a copy.
- File your state’s seller notice promptly. Deadlines vary by state. California says sellers must submit a Notice of Transfer and Release of Liability within 5 days. Texas says filing a Vehicle Transfer Notification within 30 days protects you from the buyer’s parking tickets and tolls. See our release of liability guide and your state’s rules in our title guides.
Quick Scam-Proof Checklist
| Before pickup | At pickup | After pickup |
|---|---|---|
| Describe the car honestly | Confirm the price matches the written quote | File the notice of sale or release of liability |
| Get the offer in writing | Get paid before you sign over the title | Remove or return plates as your state requires |
| Ask what could change the price | Fill in the buyer’s name on the title | Cancel insurance and registration |
| Confirm towing is included | Get a signed bill of sale or receipt | Keep copies of every document |
| Check the buyer’s license if your state has a lookup | Take a photo of the signed title | Report any scam at ReportFraud.ftc.gov |
If You’ve Already Been Scammed
- Fake check: Contact your bank right away. Don’t send any more money.
- Car taken without proper payment or paperwork: File your seller notice with the DMV immediately so the record shows the transfer date, and consider a police report.
- Any scam: Report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and to the BBB’s Scam Tracker to warn others.
If your car has a major mechanical problem, like a blown engine, be extra clear about it when you request quotes. Accurate descriptions are the best defense against a last-minute price cut. When you’re ready, you can request a free offer from our buying partners, who tow for free and pay at pickup.
FAQ
What’s the most common junk car scam? For junk cars, watch for bait-and-switch pricing, where the offer drops at pickup. If you sell online, fake overpayment checks are a scam the FTC specifically warns car sellers about.
Is it safe to accept a check for a junk car? A business check from an established, licensed buyer is common. Never accept a check for more than the price, and never send money back to a buyer.
Should I pay a junk car buyer for towing? Get the full terms in writing before pickup. Be wary of anyone who asks for money before they’ve paid you.
How do I know a junk car buyer is legitimate? Check whether your state licenses dismantlers or auto recyclers and look them up. A legitimate buyer will ask for the title, give you a receipt, and won’t ask you to leave the buyer’s name blank.
Sources
- Fake check scam targets online car sellers (FTC) — how overpayment scams target car sellers and the FTC’s advice
- Don’t bank on a “cleared” check (FTC Data Spotlight) — 2019 fake check report counts, losses, and median loss
- Selling stuff online? Here’s how to avoid a scam (FTC) — fake payment notifications, cleared checks, and verification code scams
- BBB Tip: Vehicle history report scams (BBB) — the history report scam and NMVTIS-approved providers
- NMVTIS Reporting Entities (U.S. Department of Justice) — junk and salvage yard reporting requirements
- Title Transfers and Changes (California DMV) — sellers must submit a Notice of Transfer and Release of Liability within 5 days
- Used Automotive Parts Recyclers FAQ (TDLR) — Texas recycler licensing and license search
- Buying or Selling a Vehicle (Texas DMV) — Vehicle Transfer Notification within 30 days
Ready to sell your junk car?
Get a free cash offer in about 30 seconds. Towing is always free.